One of the questions I am asked often via emails or before my Workshops is – “How to identify the right stocks for investment?”
I have explained the thought process in my value investing course, through my posts, and also do so in the Workshop.
The core steps are well-known – look for simple businesses that fall under your circle of competence and avoid everything else, read their financial statements to assess their strength and also vis-a-vis their competitors, and then value them using a few intrinsic value methods.
This process covers a large part of the “action” as far as identifying sound investment opportunities is concerned.
But there is a step prior to this process as well – a step where you create the right mental framework required to identify the right investment opportunities.
This step is courtesy Howard Marks who, in his memo to investors in January 1994, lays down seven thoughts on identifying sound investments.
These are amazing ideas for the discerning investor, as these help him get into the right frame of mind before starting the hard work of finding the right opportunities for long term investment.
Without much ado, I will let Howard Marks do the talking here…
Random Thoughts on the Identification of Investment Opportunities
Howard Marks, Jan. 1994
1. No group or sector in the investment world enjoys as its birthright the promise of consistent high returns.
There is no asset class that will do well simply because of what it is. An example of this is real estate. People said, “You should buy real estate because it’s a hedge against inflation,” and “You should buy real estate because they’re not making any more.” But done at the wrong time, real estate investing didn’t work.
2. What matters most is not what you invest in, but when and at what price.
There is no such thing as a good or bad investment idea per se. For example, the selection of good companies is certainly not enough to assure good results – see Xerox, Avon, Merck and the rest of the “nifty fifty” in 1974.
Any investment can be good or bad depending on when it’s made and what price is paid. It’s been said that “any bond can be triple-A at a price.”
There is no security that is so good that it can’t be overpriced, or so bad that it can’t be underpriced.
3. The discipline which is most important in investing is not accounting or economics, but psychology.
The key is who likes the investment now and who doesn’t. Future prices changes will be determined by whether it comes to be liked by more people or fewer people in the future.
Investing is a popularity contest, and the most dangerous thing is to buy something at the peak of its popularity. At that point, all favorable facts and opinions are already factored into its price, and no new buyers are left to emerge.
The safest and most potentially profitable thing is to buy something when no one likes it. Given time its popularity, and thus its price, can only go one way: up.
Watch which asset classes they’re holding conferences for and how many people are attending. Sold-out conferences are a danger sign. You want to participate in auctions where there are only one or two buyers, not hundreds or thousands.
You want to buy things either before they’ve been discovered or after there’s been a shake-out.
4. The bottom line is that it is best to act as a contrarian.
An investment that “everyone” knows to be undervalued is an oxymoron. If everyone knows it’s undervalued, why haven’t they bought it and driven up its price? And if they have bought, how can the price still be low?
Yogi Berra said, “nobody goes to that restaurant; it’s too popular.” The equally oxy-moronic investment version is “Everybody likes that security because it’s so cheap.”
5. Book the bet that no one else will.
If everyone likes the favorite in a football game and wants to bet on it, the point spread will grow so wide that the team — as good as it is — is unlikely to be able to cover the spread. Take the other side of the bet – on the underdog.
Likewise, if everyone is too scared of junk bonds to buy them, it will become possible for you to buy them at a yield spread which not only overcompensates for the actual credit risk, but sets the stage for their being the best performing fixed income sector in the world. That was the case in late 1990.
The bottom line is that one must try to be on the other side of the question from everyone else. If everyone likes it, sell; if no one likes it, buy.
6. As Warren Buffet said, “the less care with which others conduct their affairs, the more care with which you should conduct yours.” When others are afraid, you needn’t be; when others are unafraid, you’d better be.
It is usually said that the market runs on fear and greed. I feel at any given point in time it runs on fear or greed.
As 1991 began, everyone was petrified of high yield bonds. Only the very best bonds could be issued, and thus buyers at that time didn’t have to do any credit analysis – the market did it for them. Its collective fear caused high standards to be imposed. But when investors are unafraid, they’ll buy anything. Thus the intelligent investor’s workload is much increased.
7. Gresham’s Law says “bad money drives out good.” When paper money appeared, gold disappeared. It works in investing too: bad investors drive out good.
When undemanding investors appear, they’ll buy anything. Underwriting standards fall, and it gets hard for demanding investors to find opportunities offering the return and risk balance they require, so they’re forced to the sidelines.
Demanding investors must be willing to be inactive at times.
Simple, isn’t it?
What Marks wants you to do by sharing these ideas is to have the independence of mind.
He wants you to not get swayed by what everybody else is doing and , in fact, become “psychologically astute.”
As his third thought states – The discipline which is most important in investing is not accounting or economics, but psychology.
People who are not psychologically astute consistently make errors of judgement, something I stress upon in my Workshop.
Now the problem here is that despite appreciating the importance of this thought (and others as outlined above) in our investment framework, we often forget them in the heat of things – like when we are making or losing money fast.
Here’s what you can do to remember these thoughts before you sit down to identify the next stock for your portfolio – write them down in your “Diary of the Dumb Investor”.
By the way, my Workshop in Kolkata last Saturday received an amazing response, with 23 tribesmen attending the same (the most so far in a single Workshop).
Here are the happy tribesmen after the Workshop… 🙂
I extend my heartfelt thanks to everyone who attended the Kolkata Workshop, as also to Mr. Kanak Jain of Suskan Institute Of Graphology And Personal Success, who lent tremendous support in organizing the workshop.
This tribe is awesome! Touchwood!
Good & crisp. Having said that, needs tremendous amount of discipline to put these in to practice
Thank you for nice article. I am commenting first time but has been regular reader of your block for last few months.
I am really interested to attend your next workshop. The only request is please see if you can arrange it in Pune 🙂
Simple one vishal.. But commonsense is not common
many thanks Vishal ji,
for such a wonderful article, i am an ardent fan of the articles posted on you blog, they carry an enormous value and are very useful in making an individual a better investor.
keep posting such stuff. and happy value investing to all , as the mkt seems to be losing the steam as teh budget nears.
Parag Bora says
it was pleasure going thru ur posts…… Those r really wonderful…. ppl like m understand becoz majority of times u explain in lay mans language with very simple examples.I m eager to atten your work shop if u r ready conduct in pune……… so let m know when r coming to pune…….